Your Church Is Already Marketing Itself. Here's How to Do It on Purpose.

If the word "marketing" makes you wince, you're not alone. Plenty of pastors hear it and think slick, corporate, sales-driven. But according to an article from CareyNieuwhof.com, you're likely marketing your church already, whether you've named it that or not.

The article reframes church marketing as communication: sharing who you are, what you believe, and why it matters to people who need to hear it. Most churches are already doing pieces of this without a strategy behind it—branding through signage and social profiles, weekly video content, word-of-mouth invitations. The article walks through five organic digital tactics (website, SEO, social media, email, online community) and argues consistency matters more than production value.

For growth-minded leaders, the takeaway is less about adding new tactics and more about connecting the ones you're already running. A church that preaches well but has a confusing website or an inactive Google listing is losing people before they ever walk through the door. Communication gaps cost visitors just as much as ministry gaps do.

Three ways to sharpen your church's marketing this week:

  1. Search "church near me." See if your church shows up on the first page. If it doesn't, your website's local SEO needs attention before you spend money on ads.

  2. Pull up your website on your phone. Check that service times, location, and next steps for visitors are obvious within ten seconds.

  3. Send one plain-text email. Skip the graphics and templates. A personal, real-sounding message from a real person tends to outperform polished newsletters.

Ministry Intel

Thom Rainer argues that most church outreach programs fail for a simple reason: the program becomes the goal instead of the tool. A church fills its calendar, recruits volunteers, and checks the box when the event ends, but few members can explain what actually changed as a result. Rainer points to structural causes, including outward focus never being set as a membership expectation, evangelism training that feels scripted rather than natural, and outreach getting outsourced to a small committee while the rest of the congregation opts out. His fix is building a culture where outward focus is expected, taught, and modeled from day one, not treated as a side ministry.

This week: Before your next outreach event, ask your team Rainer's core question: what do we want members to keep doing after this program ends? If no one can answer, the event needs a clearer purpose before it needs a bigger budget.

Attorney Richard Hammar's abuse-prevention checklist, first built in the early 1990s with five screening steps, has grown to 14. One of the most significant updates: churches should stop accepting personal references from youth worker applicants altogether. Hammar cites FBI research showing that pedophiles' only adult friendships tend to be with other pedophiles, which makes personal references unreliable by design. Instead, he calls institutional references, from a school, another church, or a youth sports program that has actually observed the applicant with minors, the "gold standard." Churches should also log the date, time, and content of every reference call, ideally with a second person on the line to witness and sign the notes.

This week: Pull your current volunteer application. If it still lists personal references as an acceptable option, revise the form before your next round of youth or children's ministry hires.

Growth Toolkit

Carey Nieuwhof's upcoming book, releasing September 15, outlines three shifts churches need to make as AI reshapes work, truth, and community. Pre-ordering now unlocks a free 35+ page executive summary you can start applying immediately.

A research-driven initiative from Barna exploring the pressures pastors face and what helps them sustain healthy ministry long-term. Includes free articles, data snapshots, and podcast episodes. A good starting point for leadership teams who want to take pastoral health seriously.

What would you like to see more of? Hit reply and let us know.

You're receiving this because you care about growing healthy churches. Forward this to a fellow pastor who could use some encouragement.